Columbo's Pizza

Kenton Glick 3 months ago

Don’t let the modest store front fool you this is good tasty pizza, nice crust. They advertise their Stromboli “is the best on the planet” so I had to try it and it did not disappoint!! Seriously one of the tastiest strombolis ever!!

Brandon Balmer 4 months ago

Got a cheesesteak, pizza, and Stromboli. The dough was fresh for all of them. However in the cheesesteak and Stromboli there was little to no meat. I mean a cheesesteak should have at least 12oz of meat if not more so it’s overflowing. The Boli should be packed. Was pretty disappointed because the pizza sauce and dough were really good

Larry Sheets 5 months ago

My wife and my grandson and myself are in Lancaster for the weekend just to get away and do some shopping. Decided to give Columbo’s a try since it was close to our hotel. Big mistake! We ordered a small pepperoni pizza, a medium works pizza, and a cheesesteak with lettuce and mayo. The pizza didn’t have much sauce or it disappeared while cooking. Neither pizza tasted good. My wife also said they put too much seasoning on her cheesesteak when the menu mentioned nothing about seasoning. Needless to say most of that meal went in the trash. Lack of customers on a Friday evening should have been an indicator. Also, it took almost an hour to get our food. Live and learn.

Ray Metzger II a year ago

If I were anyone else this would be a 4 & maybe even a 5 overall!!! So if you are reading this…. This place is good. Marinara great flavor, robust some spice & complexity. Mozzarella Sticks hot, buttery, cooked to perfection. This reviewer couldn’t decide the age old question. “To dip or not to dip?” The cheeseburger sub, hot fresh, SEASONED (hallelujah!!!) tasted great. Unfortunately, was light. Suggestion for owners: IMHO, Meat should be end to end, lettuce & filler should rise above the bread. This was a 1/2 patty & 1 pinch of lettuce from perfect. Mayo was sweet, which is not my fave, however because it was well seasoned I didn’t mind as much. If you are going to go sweet use Miracle Whip 🤢. Cheese was good. The outside & inside unassuming. A lot of taped signage, guest expectation postings which is 1 of many of my pet peeves. Give them a try, you will not be disappointed.

Stephen Young 3 years ago

We love this place very much. It did have a change of owners and employees, but they are still great and kept things how they were for the most part and added a lot more to the menu. They did make some small changes to make things even better. We do miss the old staff but the new owner and staff are very nice and hardworking and we like them a lot. This place makes the best pizza in Lancaster County, strombolis are pretty good, and so are the subs. Just wish they would drop the Pepsi products for Coke products. The prices are reasonable and usually better than anywhere else. My entire family has been coming here for years. We are never disappointed. The only negative thing I could say is that their dining room could use a remodel. But we usually get takeout/delivery. We go out to many different pizza places almost every Friday night, but most of the time, we end up just getting Columbos if we can't all agree on a new place. We also love Rosa Rosa and Two Cousins on Columbia Ave near Tobias Frog. Thanks for the years of great food and service, and I will probably keep coming till I'm 6 ft under.